NMJAS 2022 Judging Forms

Judges' links

General links

NMJAS judging forms & documents

Please note: The judging criteria and format have changed, based on feedback from 2021. 

The general categories for manuscript judging are: mechanics & effort (20%); clarity (30%); analytical approach (20%); thoroughness (20%); and creativity (10%).

The general categories for oral presentation judging are: dynamics (20%); narrative (40%); visuals (10%); and questioning (30)%. 

Judges’ forms

Manuscript judging form Microsoft Word | pdf
Oral presentation judging form Microsoft Word | pdf

Judge’s critique form (return to student)
Judge’s evaluation form (return to Lynn Brandovold)

Student forms

Student manuscript checklist