NMJAS 2023 Forms
Judges links
General links
NMJAS forms & documents
The judging criteria and format were changed in 2022, based on feedback from 2021.
The general categories for manuscript judging are:
– mechanics & effort (20%)
– clarity (30%)
– analytical approach (20%)
– thoroughness (20%)
– creativity (10%)
The general categories for oral presentation judging are:
– dynamics (20%)
– narrative (40%)
– visuals (10%)
– questioning (30)%.
Judges’ forms
Note: version 1 of each has a single scoring column with a scale of 1-10 and can be used with online scoring; version 2 has a second scoring column for you to calculate actual points by applying the category weight.
Manuscript judging forms
Microsoft Word – version1
Microsoft Word – version 2
PDF – version 1
PDF – version 2
Oral presentation judging forms
Microsoft Word – version1
Microsoft Word – version 2
PDF – version 1
PDF – version 2
Judge’s critique form (return to student)
Judge’s evaluation form (return to Lynn Brandovold)